all star products logo white

What is the Best Material for a Front Door?

Table of Contents

When it comes to choosing the ideal front door for your home, the decision holds more significance than you might initially think. You’re not just selecting a point of entry; you’re determining the best material for a front door, one that can transform your home into an expression of your unique personality and style. In this article, we’ll explore the various options available and unveil why fiberglass doors consistently stand out as the preferred choice among homeowners.

Different Types of Front Doors

When it comes to front entry doors, you’re presented with a wide array of solutions. Steel front doors, wood front doors, and fiberglass front doors are among the most common options available in the market. Then there are what some might call the “Home Depot specials,” which, while budget-friendly, may not deliver the desired quality.

Each type of front door has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the choice largely depends on your design preferences and requirements. However, in this article, we’re going to focus on why fiberglass doors are often considered the best choice.

Why I Prefer Fiberglass Doors

Fiberglass doors have gained popularity, especially in regions with challenging weather conditions like Chicago. One of the primary reasons why many homeowners, including myself, prefer fiberglass doors is their durability and performance.

Performance and Durability of Fiberglass Doors

Unlike steel entry doors, which are also energy-efficient but prone to denting, fiberglass doors are known for their resilience. In harsh climates, where extreme temperatures and adverse weather are the norm, a fiberglass front door remains dimensionally stable. This stability ensures that the door functions flawlessly, whether it’s the peak of winter or the height of summer. It can withstand the impact of kids’ boots, deliveries, and daily wear and tear.

Design Options and Warranty of Fiberglass Doors

Another significant advantage of fiberglass doors is the extensive range of design options they offer. You can achieve the look of a real wood door with fiberglass while enjoying superior performance and energy efficiency. Whether you desire a classic, rustic, or modern aesthetic, there’s a fiberglass door design to match your taste.

Furthermore, many fiberglass doors come with warranties, providing peace of mind to homeowners. This warranty ensures that your investment is protected, and you can count on your front door for years to come.

Limitations of Wood Doors

While wood doors can be stunning and offer a traditional, timeless appeal, they do come with their own set of limitations. One major drawback is the lack of a warranty. Most wood doors do not come with a warranty, leaving homeowners vulnerable to potential issues without any manufacturer support.

Additionally, wood doors often require specific placement conditions, such as having an overhang and protection from direct sunlight. These restrictions can make wood doors less suitable for homeowners living in harsh environments or those seeking low-maintenance options.


When it comes to selecting the best material for a front door, fiberglass emerges as a clear frontrunner. Its unmatched durability, wide-ranging design options, and the assurance of a warranty make it a top choice for homeowners looking to invest in a door that not only enhances the aesthetics of their home but also withstands the test of time and environmental challenges.

If you’re interested in exploring the possibilities of upgrading your front door to a fiberglass masterpiece, please don’t hesitate to contact us. Our team is always here to help you with your door replacement needs.

dave donofrio

Dave Donofrio

Owner & CEO

Dave Donofrio is owner and CEO of All Star Products, LLC.  After a two decade career at James Hardie, Dave partnered with the team at All Star to bring advances in exterior remodeling material and technology, while preserving the family friendly, customer oriented approached that been the key to All Star’s success over the last 35 years.


Google Rating
Based on 54 reviews